Browse
Membership
Why join? Member benefits Healthcare HMCA discounts benefits For Individuals For Students and ECTs For Educational Institutions NSEAD Member Assistance Programme New Member Portal Join Us
Resources
The Big Landscape Curriculum Primary Education Anti-Racist Art Education Research, reports and reviews Units of Work Drawing Design Craft Digital Media NSEAD 22 Video Library Health & Safety Ofsted Research Review
Publications
iJADE AD Magazine START library Books NSEAD Shop Archive Life after lockdown #NSEADcreate: Learning Online
Courses & Events
Events CPD and Training E-Learning
Professional Learning Community
About NSEAD NSEAD Awards Advocacy Policy and Research NSEAD Directories Regional Networks Groups
News
Trade Union
Trade Union: Industrial Action Advice About the union How to seek help Legal advice & aid Trade Union FAQs Health and Safety Updates Careers advice COVID-19 Advice and Guidance Useful Links Introducing Sensitive Topics into the Art, Craft and Design Curriculum TOOLKIT
Join Us

On the 4th November the Dfe announced additional funding for P16-19 Education

Education Secretary Gavin Williamson said:

“We want all young people to have access to high-quality education and training that will set them on the path to a rewarding career. Next year colleges and school sixth forms will benefit from a significant £400 million funding boost to help them to do this.”

And, “An extra £65 million will be targeted to help cover the cost of delivering courses in six key, more expensive subject areas, and an additional £55 million will be allocated for delivering high value courses – those that deliver the skills the country needs for the future and which lead to higher wages for students.” This is welcome news for the FE sector which has suffered from long term under-investment.

However, NSEAD is dismayed that Creative arts are not included in the list of 'expensive subject areas' and that this funding has been awarded according to a so called ‘ High Value Courses Premium’ that excludes many areas of study - including most Art & Design and Expressive Arts courses. We believe that the basis for the High Value Courses Premium is fundamentally flawed and directly undermines the stated intention of this announcement. By excluding the vast majority of creative arts courses, this funding ignores the true contribution to the economy of graduates from creative design, and the importance of the creative economy to the prosperity of the UK.

We reject the premise that courses in the creative arts do not deliver the skills that the country needs for the future. We take issue with the implication that careers in the creative arts are not ‘rewarding’. We challenge the use of data and definitions of value that are both incomplete and narrow in their terms of reference.

Earlier this year a presentation was made to the Art Craft and Design APPG by Gordon McKenzie from Guild HE pointing out the limitations of outcome based success measures.

A report by London Economics, identified in a report jointly commissioned by GuildHE and the HEAD Trust highlighted critical gaps in the data and strongly cautioned against using LEO as the only indicator of graduate success in the labour market. The report identified the limitations of LEO data when used to judge outcomes for graduates in the creative arts for leaving out factors that have a significant influence on earnings and employment. In particular;

● LEO data only covers graduates’ earnings and employment in the early stages of their careers;
and

● LEO data provides incomplete and potentially inaccurate data on earnings from self-employment.

The Ad-hoc notice Post 16 education: earnings outcomes for level 3 achievements that accompanied the DFE's announcement, explaining how the ‘High value’ rating has been defined, carries a health warning on it’s own data:

‘The estimates should therefore be treated with a degree of caution as there is a large amount of unexplained variation in the data.’

Why has this data been used as the basis for such a signifcant funding policy?

We would also ask how this funding announcement is addressing the priorities set out in the Government’s Industry Strategy, which fully recognises the importance of the creative economy.

Earlier this year, NSEAD was a signatory to the open letter to Gavin Williamson,
led by the Creative Industries Federation drawing his attention to the dangers of a skills shortage.

“The creative industries are growing at twice the rate of the UK economy, and employ more than 2 million people. Jobs in the sector are growing at three times the UK average, and analysis by Nesta outlines that with proper investment an additional one million creative jobs could be added to the UK economy by 2030. But it is estimated that there are more than 77,000 roles that are unfilled or which require additional skills.”

This new funding policy takes no account of this growing skills gap. We call upon the DFE to review the list of High Value Courses and the criteria on which the premium is based.

Art & Design and Expressive Arts courses feed the creative economy. They are high cost to deliver, but are of high value to our economy and society at large. It is disturbing that such a significant funding decision is based on data that the DFE accepts is limited and incomplete, and that ignores the evidence about the skills needs of the sector, and the crucial contribution that the creative industries continue to make.

Back
When
14th November 2019
Share

See the latest NSEAD News Stories

Standardising portfolios for art and design-related university applications
news

Further to issues raised by the NSEAD community about the process and impact of multiple portfolio generation on students, we conducted an indicative…

Find out more
School Funding and Pupil Premium Report
news

The Sutton Trust have published a report which shows the impact of the cost of living crisis on the financial pressures this is taking on school budgets.

Find out more
How can we build strong foundations for the future of the Arts in schools?
news

Today saw the release of a new report The Arts in Schools: Foundations for the Future, published by A New Direction and the Calouste Gulbenkian Foundation…

Find out more
NFER’s Annual Teacher Labour Market Report 2023
news
Initial Teacher Education

NFER’s Annual Teacher Labour Market report monitors on the progress in the recruitment system in England. The report predicts that there will be continued…

Find out more
Learn More
About NSEAD T&Cs Support us Funding from the Paul Hamlyn Foundation Legal / Privacy News Letter Invest in arts subjects to protect our children’s futures
Company
Support our work
Support
01225 810134 Contact Us
Advertise with us
Learn more
Follow Us
© 2023 NSEAD | All Rights Reserved
Site by Grandad Digital